When picking packaging for deodorant products, stick bottles and roll-ons are the two most popular choices. While the two types are designed for the same intended purpose, the packaging, user experience, and types of customers the brands cater to for the designs differ. Knowing the differences can help both consumers and brands make choices that fit the intended purpose and personal preference.
Deodorant stick bottles contain solid or semi-solid deodorant placed in twist-up tubes or push-up holders. They also come with protective caps to keep everything sterile and avoid contamination. Their outer casings are also rigid and compact, which enables the users to handle the sticks without directly touching the formulation.
Conversely, roll-on deodorants are liquid or gel deodorants placed in cylindrical bottles that come with ball applicators. The ball is housed in a socket that controls the quantity of deodorant released with every application. To top everything, the bottles come with screw-on caps designed to cap the contents and stop leakage during transport or store.
To use a stick deodorant, simply glide the stick against your skin; there’s no mess and no need for extra application. The deodorant formulation does not drip, overflow, or spread to places that were not targeted. It provides instant coverage, and it smoothens skin, and does not leave a greasy feeling, and is perfect for anytime use. It quickly dries skin, which is perfect for active users.
To use a roll-on, you have to tip the bottle to get the liquid to the roll-on. The roll-on deodorant provides gentle use and provides a fairly complete application. The deodorant liquid gradually absorbs into skin, which some prefer for the cooling effect. With a roll-on, there is no need to rush as it does take time to dry completely.
Packaged deodorant sticks are designed for cream or solid formulations. These formulations have wax, powder, and thickening agents that help the stick-form remain unbending or breakable with gentle pressure. The pack-s twist up is the perfect designed as it provides a means to control the knob and avoid breaking the stick.
Roll on containers are designed for deodorants in liquid or gel form and thinner consistency. This makes it easy for the liquid to flow through the ball applicator, which helps in controlling the amount that gets dispensed. Having more water or alcohol in the ingredient mix works with the roll on's dispensing system.
Deodorant stick bottles are compact and leak proof, which makes them easy to carry around. Because there is no chance of spills with the solid formulation, they can be taken on trips, to the gym, or dropped in purses without a second thought. There is no fuss to use them—just twisted up and apply, no shaking or adjustments are needed.
Roll on containers can be taken on the go but are more prone to leaks if not stored properly. While many modern roll on containers have secure caps, the liquid can spill if the container is tipped over for a long time. Their design favors vertical storage and this can limit convenience for certain traveling situations.
People with sensitive skin tend to prefer deodorant sticks. They're easier to use, and the solid form keeps contact to a minimum, which means less irritation. Also, many deodorant sticks are hypoallergenic.
Because of the liquid form of roll-ons, they are more likely to irritate sensitive skin. Also, alcohol can increase the risk of irritation on sensitive or recently shaved skin and can lead to dryness, stinging, and irritation. That said, there are roll-ons for sensitive skin with no alcohol, no fragrance, and no irritating ingredients.
People who want to use a deodorant stick tend to like speed and ease of use. It's great for the morning rush, a quick dry application, or after a workout when you want to freshen up. Also, the solid form is great for people who want to use "traditional" deodorant sticks.
Users who appreciate even distribution and a cooling effect prefer roll on containers. Roll on containers can also be used on the evenings or whenever the product can dry before dressing. With the liquid formula, consumers who want lasting protection appreciate the formulation as it bonds more effective with the skin.
EN